Westside Stories: Matthew & Nichole Stone

Matthew and Nichole Stone's episode closes out Westside Stories Season 5, and it's a fitting way to end a season built around honest, hard-won hope. Their story is about what it looks like to say "yes" to something you can't fully understand yet, and then to keep saying "yes."
Matthew was adopted himself, born in South Korea before growing up outside Grand Rapids, Michigan. That history sat quietly in the back of his mind for years. Nichole, raised in a churchgoing family in South Dakota, had been exposed to adoption through ministry but didn't know it would become central to her own story. The decision came together fast, a conversation in the car after meeting a teacher who had adopted out of foster care, and a week later, they were signed up for foster parenting classes.
What followed moved quickly. Their first placement, an eleven-month-old baby boy, arrived less than 24 hours after they were licensed. Within a year, they'd gone from zero children to three, including their son Marcus, whom they adopted after being unexpectedly selected from a pool of foster families for a legal-risk case. Matthew and Nichole are careful to note that fostering was never a backdoor to adoption for them. They went in believing the best place for a child is with their biological family, and they meant it, even when it cost them.

That belief was tested directly. One little boy, a toddler close in age to Marcus, lived with them for about a year before he was reunified with his biological family, a moment Matthew and Nichole describe as genuinely good for him and genuinely painful for them at the same time. It's the kind of tension that runs through their whole story: joy and grief showing up in the same rooms, often on the same day.
A move to Boston, and later to Atlanta, didn't end their calling to foster, even through stretches where they wondered if their story in this particular chapter was finished. Now, as their children grow older, Matthew and Nichole talk about a different kind of faithfulness, sitting with their oldest son's hard questions about why he doesn't live with his first parents, resisting the urge to hand him easy answers, and choosing instead to sit in the uncertainty with him.

Asked what they'd say to each other after everything, Matthew names Nichole's graciousness through every hard conversation with caseworkers and biological families. Nichole names Matthew's tenacity, the willingness to take the next step even when neither of them fully knew what they were signing up for.
As you listen, we want to invite you to sit with one question: how is God calling you to step into the messy? Ask Him for the peace and courage to do so today.
And a challenge, if you're willing: call, text, or meet up with a close friend. Share a few moments when you felt out of control and afraid, and yet the Lord met you. Point out where you can see His fingerprints on every step that brought you to where you are today.
Listen now on Spotify or Apple Podcasts, or find the full episode on our website.
Thank you for joining us for Westside Stories Season 5. Stay tuned for Season 6!
More blog posts
Stay connected with our newsletter
Subscribe to our Weekly Westsider newsletter for church updates, event opportunities, and new media and content.
.avif)


